Coterie Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Craft Beer

Coterie Pizza is a dining establishment located in Auburn, Garrett, offering a menu centered on pizza, Italian cuisine, and craft beer. This location serves individuals seeking casual meals that combine traditional Italian flavors with a selection of local craft beer options.

A look at Coterie Pizza's menu and price range

Sausage
Vota illustration
Sausage$10.99
Classic Penne
Vota illustration
Classic Penne$6.99
Spinach Artichoke Pizza
Vota illustration
Spinach Artichoke Pizza$12.95
Vota

See the full menu

Get the free Vota app

The menu at Coterie Pizza in Auburn features a variety of stone fired pasta dishes ranging from $6.99 to $8.99, alongside a selection of stone baked sandwiches priced between $9.99 and $10.99. Customers can choose from several pizza creations, including popular items like the brisket pizza at $14.95 or the classic margherita at $11.99, while appetizers like beer cheese dip and cheese bread are available for $6.99 and $7.99 respectively. Coterie Pizza provides a straightforward dining environment that reflects the broader culinary landscape of Garrett, where the focus remains on staple comfort foods. The area maintains a modest pace of life, often drawing comparisons to the quiet, industrial-adjacent towns found throughout the American Midwest. Locals here prioritize consistency over culinary trends, favoring meals that pair easily with a pint after a long work week. In this part of the state, the food culture is defined by utilitarian, hearty plates that serve as a social anchor for the community. Auburn serves as a functional hub where the proximity to historic rail lines still influences the local aesthetic and the way residents gather for dinner.

  • Coterie Pizza specializes in stone fired pizza, pasta, and sandwiches.
  • The restaurant provides a selection of craft beer alongside Italian-inspired dishes.
  • Most pasta dishes on the menu are priced between $6.99 and $8.99.
  • Specialty pizza creations are available with prices ranging from $11.99 to $14.95.
  • This casual venue is suitable for families and residents looking for a neighborhood dining spot.

Created on Oct 29, 2026

This article was created by Vota’s editorial team with the help of AI.

AddressS Randolph St, IN
CityGarrett, United States of America

Location

Vota recommends

What are you in the mood for?

The ranking

Best Pizza in Auburn

7 places ranked by guests