The Property

Casual Dining · Coffee Shop

The Property is a venue in Columbus that functions as both a casual dining destination and a coffee shop. It serves a diverse range of food categories including steaks, sandwiches, salads, and various bakery items.

Menu and pricing at The Property

12 Ounce New York Strip
Vota illustration
12 Ounce New York Strip$62
Annex Steak Sandwich
Vota illustration
Annex Steak Sandwich$16
8 Ounce Filet Mignon
Vota illustration
8 Ounce Filet Mignon$53
Vota

See the full menu

Get the free Vota app

The Property in Columbus features an extensive menu with a wide price range for various dishes. Indiana beef selections such as the 8 Ounce Sirloin are priced at $24, while the 20 Ounce Porterhouse reaches $110 and the Bone-in Tomahawk is $250. Diners can find starters starting at $12 for a Tomato and Onion Salad up to $53 for a Chilled Seafood Platter, with main courses like the Cauliflower Steak at $28 and Scallops at $53. The bakery and sandwich sections offer items such as a $7 croffle and a $16 Annex Steak Sandwich, providing options for different dining times. Columbus functions as a central hub for Midwestern commerce and education, mirroring the growth patterns seen in cities like Austin or Raleigh. The local food culture relies heavily on the accessibility of high-quality proteins paired with casual, high-frequency dining formats. Residents and visitors frequent this area to engage with a blend of traditional regional agriculture and contemporary culinary techniques. This specific location provides a necessary intersection between a quick morning coffee stop and a structured evening seated dining experience.

  • The Property is located in Columbus and operates as a casual dining space and coffee shop.
  • The menu includes a wide variety of items ranging from $4 snacks to a $250 Bone-in Tomahawk.
  • Indiana beef cuts are a core component of the menu, with prices starting at $24.
  • The establishment offers kid-friendly options like $8 hot dogs and $9 chicken tenders.
  • Seated dining experiences and tasting menus are available for $125 and $145.

Created on Oct 30, 2026

This article was created by Vota’s editorial team with the help of AI.

Address9250 S State Road 58, Columbus, IN 47201-5001, USA
CityColumbus, United States

Location

Vota recommends

What are you in the mood for?

The ranking

Best Casual Dining in Columbus

4 places ranked by guests