Elkhart Italian

40 places in Elkhart, Indiana

Olive Garden and Noodles and Company are the best-rated Italian restaurants in Elkhart, Indiana. See all 10 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.

62
Highest rated
Olive Garden
Rated places
10
Average score
20/ 100
Most popular dish
Cheese Pizza
Antonio's Italian
Antonio's Italian

Italian · Pizza · Casual Dining

Goshen Ave

Takeout is available for pizzas like the Italian Stallion for $33. The La Famiglia set menu includes Grilled Salmon for $2.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Freshieez
Freshieez

Pizza · Ice Cream Shop · Italian

County Road 6

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Cappy's Northside
Cappy's Northside

Italian · Burger · Steakhouse

North Dr

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Bambino's Home Pizza
Bambino's Home Pizza

Pizza · Italian

Cassopolis St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Saylor's Pizza & More
Saylor's Pizza & More

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

Oakland Ave

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Bruno's Pizza
Bruno's Pizza

Pizza · Italian

IN

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Volcano Pizza
Volcano Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

Poplar Ct

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery
Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery

Italian · Pizza · Sandwich Shop

S Nappanee St, 2930 S Nappanee St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Milano's Pizza
Milano's Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining

S Main St

The menu includes classic Italian entrees like Lasagna for $12.95, alongside a variety of subs, salads, and sides.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Jimtown Pizza
Jimtown Pizza

Pizza · Ice Cream Shop · Italian

County Road 3

Serving pizza and ice cream, including Pizza Bread for $6, alongside a variety of sides like mozzarella sticks. Open Tuesday through Sunday.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Hall's Kitchen Pizza and Subs
Hall's Kitchen Pizza and Subs

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

S Nappanee St

This menu features thin-crust pizza starting at $8.99, plus a variety of subs like the Classic Italian or Meatball Marinara for $10.50.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Rulli's
Rulli's

Italian · Pizza

County Road 17

This menu features handmade Italian dishes like Pasta Carciofi for $14.49, alongside a variety of 12" and 16" pizzas and appetizers like Chicken Tenders.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Big City Pizza
Big City Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

Northview Dr

Serving a variety of cauliflower crust pizzas, such as the Seattle Supreme for $16, alongside sandwiches and comfort food.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Callahan's
Callahan's

American · Italian · Greek

Cassopolis St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano
Per Bacco Ristorante Italiano

Italian · Casual Dining

28046 County Road 16

The menu features dishes like Italian Wedding for $3.50, Ravioli for $16.95, and Lasagna for $15.90.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Bruno's Pizza
Bruno's Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

County Road 16

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Michael's Italian
Michael's Italian

Italian · Family Style · Casual Dining

Harrison St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Cappy's Northside
Cappy's Northside

American · Italian · Bar and Grill

IN

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Antonio's
Antonio's

Italian · Pizza · Casual Dining

1105 Goshen Ave

Handcrafted appetizers and traditional pastas include the Italian Stallion for $33. The La Famiglia set menu features Grilled Salmon for $2.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Samuel Mancinos
Samuel Mancinos

Italian · Pizza · Family Style

S Division St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices