High Score Saloon is a bar and grill located in Evansville that specializes in American cuisine. This establishment serves a variety of pizza options by the slice or as whole pies.
High Score Saloon
The menu at High Score Saloon in Evansville focuses on pizza, offering both individual slices and full pies. Guests can choose from options like meatza, cheese, pepperoni, or sausage, alongside a rotating pizza of the week. Prices for a single slice range from $5 to $6, while whole pies are priced between $23 and $30. This price range reflects the distinction between ordering by the slice and purchasing a complete pizza. Evansville maintains a straightforward dining culture centered on accessible, hearty fare that serves as a social anchor for the local community. The area reflects a classic Midwestern approach to hospitality, prioritizing consistency and casual settings over elaborate presentation. Much like the industrial heritage found in cities across the Ohio River Valley, local eating habits prioritize function and communal gathering spaces. Residents often gravitate toward spots that offer a reliable experience, viewing the local food scene as an extension of their living rooms rather than a performance. This preference for the practical ensures that neighborhood haunts remain the primary engine of the local culinary landscape. * High Score Saloon operates as a bar and grill in Evansville. * The menu exclusively features pizza by the slice and as whole pies. * Individual slices are available for $5 or $6. * Whole pies are priced between $23 and $30. * The location serves as a casual gathering spot for local residents.
Created on Oct 30, 2026
This article was created by Vota’s editorial team with the help of AI.
Location
Vota recommends
What are you in the mood for?
American in Evansville
Here are the city's 234 places. The darker the red, the more of them. The 4 highest rated are marked with their score.

Best places nearby
The highest rated places close to High Score Saloon.
Local restaurants nearby
Main St, IN






