Holy Smokes Barbecue
BBQ · American · Sandwich Shop
Holy Smokes Barbecue is a destination for those seeking traditional American barbecue and hearty sandwich shop staples in Gary. This establishment focuses on smoked meats, classic sides, and varied combo plates designed for both individual diners and larger groups. The menu at Holy Smokes Barbecue in Gary features a wide selection of smoked meats priced by the quarter pound, including pork spareribs for $35, brisket for $14, and smoked chicken for $12. Combo plates range from $18 for a single meat option to $69 for a sampler platter, while signature sandwiches like the $19 Texas Trinity and $18 smoked brisket cheesesteak serve as popular items. Desserts such as banana pudding and pecan pie are available for $6 each, and family meals are offered at $90 or $180 depending on the group size. Gary maintains a pragmatic food culture rooted in the industrial history of the Midwest, where the demand for substantial, high-calorie meals remains a constant. The area reflects a working-class culinary tradition that prioritizes utility and flavor over delicate presentation. Similar to the meat-heavy traditions found in regions like Kansas City or parts of Texas, the local preference leans toward slow-cooked proteins that sustain residents through long days. This approach to dining is less about performance and more about providing a predictable, reliable caloric foundation for the community.
- The restaurant specializes in American BBQ and sandwich shop staples.
- Individual meat portions are sold by the 1/4lb, with prices starting at $7.
- Combo plates offer a structured way to dine, priced between $18 and $69.
- Family meals are available for groups of four or eight at $90 or $180.
- The location serves as a central hub for barbecue enthusiasts in Gary.
Download the Vota app for iPhone and Android for the full menu and detailed information.
Created on Oct 30, 2026
This article was created by Vota’s editorial team with the help of AI.
Location
Vota recommends
What are you in the mood for?
Best places nearby
The highest rated places close to Holy Smokes Barbecue.
Local restaurants nearby
4121 Cleveland St, Gary, Indiana





