Arrenello's Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Seafood

A look at Arrenello's Pizza's menu and price range

Medium Jumbo Shrimp
Vota illustration
Medium Jumbo Shrimp
Buffalo Breast Strips
Vota illustration
Buffalo Breast Strips$9.45
Salsa
Vota illustration
Salsa$0.40
Vota

See the full menu

Get the free Vota app

This establishment in Highland specializes in pizza, Italian cuisine, and seafood. It functions as a local destination for those seeking traditional pies, pasta dishes, and various fried seafood options.

The menu and price range at Arrenello's Pizza in Highland feature a wide selection of appetizers, pasta, sandwiches, and crust variations. Most appetizers like mozzarella sticks or potato skins are available for $6.50 to $12.75, while pasta dishes such as spaghetti or fettucini alfredo typically range from $12.95 to $19.95. The menu highlights different pizza crust styles including thin, extra thick, and stuffed, with prices for these pies varying based on size and added ingredients. Diners can also select from various seafood options like cod and jumbo shrimp, alongside chicken dinners and wings.

Highland maintains a classic Midwestern residential character, mirroring the steady, unpretentious pace found in suburban pockets surrounding Chicago. The local food culture prioritizes hearty portions and reliable comfort food, a legacy of the migration patterns that brought Italian culinary staples into the heart of the American industrial belt. Residents here value consistency over culinary trends, viewing a neighborhood kitchen as a communal anchor rather than a theater for invention. This area functions as a quiet study in domestic stability, where the local palate remains deeply attached to the familiar textures of baked cheese and breaded proteins.

  • Arrenello's Pizza is located in Highland and offers a diverse menu of pizza, Italian classics, and seafood.
  • The restaurant provides a variety of chicken dinners and wings, catering to casual dining and group settings.
  • Appetizers and pasta dishes generally fall within a price range of $4.50 to $19.95 per item.
  • Pizza prices vary by crust style, with thin, extra thick, and stuffed options available for selection.
  • The location is suitable for families and individuals looking for traditional, straightforward American-Italian meals.

Download the Vota app for iPhone and Android for the full menu and detailed information.

Created on Oct 29, 2026

This article was created by Vota’s editorial team with the help of AI.

Address45th St, IN
CityHighland, United States of America

Location

Vota recommends

What are you in the mood for?

Best places nearby

The highest rated places close to Arrenello's Pizza.

Local restaurants nearby

45th St, IN

The ranking

Best Pizza in Highland

3 places ranked by guests