Pots & Pans Pie Co

Bakery · Dessert Shop · American

Menu and pricing at Pots & Pans Pie Co

6" Mac & Cheese
Vota illustration
6" Mac & Cheese$42
Walking Taco
Vota illustration
Walking Taco$6.50
6" Beef & Mushroom Pot Pie
Vota illustration
6" Beef & Mushroom Pot Pie$16
Vota

See the full menu

Get the free Vota app

Pots & Pans Pie Co is a bakery, dessert shop, and American restaurant located in the Warren Township area of Indianapolis. The establishment specializes in a variety of house-made pies, pastries, and savory comfort foods. This venue serves those seeking traditional baked goods and American classics in a straightforward setting. The menu features a wide selection of savory pot pies, including options like classic chicken, beef and mushroom, and green chile pork. Guests can also select from various sweet pies, cookies, and other bakery items, with pot pies ranging from $8 to $42 and sweet pies priced between $12 and $41. The menu also includes a selection of hot dogs, nachos, pretzels, and ice cream treats. Warren Township maintains a residential character defined by its mid-century suburban expansion and proximity to major transit corridors. The area reflects a broader Indianapolis food culture that prioritizes accessible, hearty meals over complex culinary experimentation. Local dining habits here are rooted in convenience and tradition, favoring establishments that provide consistent, recognizable comfort food without unnecessary pretense. Residents often rely on these local hubs as daily staples rather than occasional destinations, reinforcing a community-focused approach to eating that mirrors the reliable, utility-driven layout of the surrounding neighborhoods.
  • Pots & Pans Pie Co is located in Warren Township, Indianapolis.
  • The shop operates as a bakery, dessert shop, and American restaurant.
  • Savory pot pies are available in sizes ranging from 6" to 9" with prices from $8 to $42.
  • Sweet pie prices range from $12 to $41 depending on the specific flavor and size.
  • The menu includes American staples like hot dogs, nachos, and various ice cream shop offerings.

Download the Vota app for iPhone and Android for the full menu and detailed information.

Created on Oct 30, 2026

This article was created by Vota’s editorial team with the help of AI.

AddressN College Ave, IN
CityIndianapolis, United States of America

Location

Vota recommends

What are you in the mood for?

Best places nearby

The highest rated places close to Pots & Pans Pie Co.

Local restaurants nearby

N College Ave, IN

The ranking

Best Bakery in Indianapolis

25 places ranked by guests