Foster's Catering

American · Sandwich Shop

Foster's Catering operates as a sandwich shop and American eatery serving the Lawrence area in Indianapolis. The menu focuses on casual staples like burgers, sandwiches, and various rice bowls.

Menu and pricing at Foster's Catering

Chimichuri Steak
Vota illustration
Chimichuri Steak
Tuna Salad
Vota illustration
Tuna Salad
Spaghetti
Vota illustration
Spaghetti
Vota

See the full menu

Get the free Vota app

The menu at Foster's Catering in Lawrence features a consistent pricing structure where most sandwiches and cafe salads range from $5 to $8. Bowls and loaded fry options are priced between $7 and $11, while catering options vary significantly based on the specific menu selected. This establishment is aimed towards people looking for straightforward American comfort food, offering a variety of handhelds and hearty bowls that cater to quick dining needs.

  • Foster's Catering is located in Lawrence, Indianapolis, providing a mix of cafe-style meals and comprehensive catering services.
  • The restaurant features American cuisine with a focus on sandwiches, burgers, and rice-based bowls.
  • Individual menu items like burgers and sandwiches start at $5, with most loaded fry and bowl options priced up to $11.
  • The business offers extensive catering menus including breakfast, lunch, and executive options for larger groups.
  • The location serves as a practical stop for residents and visitors seeking familiar, direct American dishes in the Lawrence neighborhood.
Lawrence functions as a distinct enclave within the broader Indianapolis metropolitan area, maintaining a suburban character that balances residential density with commercial convenience. The local food culture reflects a pragmatic approach to dining, favoring accessible, high-volume preparation styles suited for both individual quick lunches and community gatherings. Unlike the dense, walkable culinary corridors found in downtown Indianapolis or the historic districts of older cities, Lawrence emphasizes utility and community-focused catering. This focus on group-oriented food service highlights a local preference for shared meals and reliable, consistent flavors over the experimental trends often seen in more tourist-heavy districts. The area provides a snapshot of midwestern efficiency, where the demand for substantial, well-priced food sustains a robust ecosystem of catering and casual service providers.

Created on Oct 29, 2026

This article was created by Vota’s editorial team with the help of AI.

AddressE 59th St, IN
CityIndianapolis, United States of America

Location

Vota recommends

What are you in the mood for?

Best places nearby

The highest rated places close to Foster's Catering.

88
Maru

Maru

Bar, Casual Dining
Vota

Haven't found it yet?

Find more places near you in the free Vota app

Local restaurants nearby

E 59th St, IN

The ranking

Best American in Lawrence

13 places ranked by guests