Goodfella's

Pizza · Italian · Bar

Goodfella's in McCordsville serves as a destination for those seeking traditional pizza, Italian cuisine, and a social bar atmosphere. This establishment provides a dedicated setting for patrons interested in classic Italian dining and wood fired brick oven pizza.

What's on Goodfella's's menu (and how much it costs)

Grilled Chicken Caesar
Vota illustration
Grilled Chicken Caesar$70
House Salad
Vota illustration
House Salad$10
Chicken Parm
Vota illustration
Chicken Parm$20
Vota

See the full menu

Get the free Vota app

The menu at Goodfella's in McCordsville offers a broad selection of appetizers including Buffalo Wings for $12 and Fried Calamari for $16, alongside various entrees like Chicken Parm for $24 and a 16 Oz NY Strip CAB for $40. Pasta dishes such as Penne Vodka are priced at $21, while pizza options from the wood fired brick oven are available for $21. The selection covers a wide range of proteins and starches, catering to those looking for substantial Italian fare within these specific price points. McCordsville maintains a suburban character that values accessible, family oriented dining establishments that anchor local social life. The surrounding area reflects the broader regional appreciation for Italian food culture, which often serves as a common ground for community gatherings. This part of Indiana prioritizes consistent, recognizable menus that cater to both casual diners and those seeking a structured meal in a familiar, neighborhood setting.

Created on Oct 29, 2026

This article was created by Vota’s editorial team with the help of AI.

AddressOlio Rd, IN
CityMcCordsville, United States of America

Location

The ranking

Best Pizza in Mccordsville

8 places, none rated yet