Middletown American
54 places in Middletown, New Jersey
Bahrs Landing and New Monmouth Diner are the best-rated American restaurants in Middletown, New Jersey. See all 9 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.
- Highest rated
- Bahrs Landing
- Rated places
- 9
- Average score
- 27/ 100

Sissy's Place
American · Breakfast · Coffee Shop
Main St
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Market Plate
American · Casual Dining · Deli
Rt 35
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Off The Hook
American · Bar · Seafood
State Route 36
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Et Al Fine Food
American
Shore Dr
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Honey Baked Ham
Sandwich Shop · American
770 Route 35
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Wilson Ave Deli
Deli · Sandwich Shop · American
Wilson Ave
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Tony & Mia's Catered Cuisine
Italian · American · Casual Dining
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

The Chubby Pickle
Bar · Bar and Grill · American
Bay Ave
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Tatum's Table
Breakfast · Brunch · American
650 Newman Springs Rd
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Flavia's Kitchen
Fast Food · American
Pennybrook Ln
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Fresh
Seafood · Casual Dining · American
144 Bay Ave
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Big Man BBQ
BBQ · American · Casual Dining
367 Thompson Ave
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Hog Heaven
BBQ · American · Fast Food
325 Shore Dr
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Belford Bistro
American · Casual Dining · Fine Dining
Main St
Not rated yetSee menu and prices