Islip Italian
27 places in Islip, New York
Domino's Pizza and Dominos Pizza are the best-rated Italian restaurants in Islip. See all 4 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.
- Highest rated
- Domino's Pizza
- Rated places
- 4
- Average score
- 19/ 100

Americano Pie Bar
Italian · Pizza · Bar
Main St
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Family Pizzeria
Pizza · Italian · Family Style
743 Commack Rd
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Tony's Pizzeria and Restaurant
Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
161 Clarke St
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Mezza Luna
Italian · Fine Dining · Bar
644 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Il Piccolo Villaggio
Italian · Casual Dining
260 Islip Ave
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Poppa Mia's Ice House
Ice Cream Shop · Coffee Shop · Italian
Main St
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Buseto Pizza
Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
Sunrise Hwy
Not rated yetSee menu and prices