Carmel Italian

32 places in Carmel, Indiana

Roselli's Pizza and Olive Garden are the best-rated Italian restaurants in Carmel. See all 6 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.

64
Highest rated
Roselli's Pizza
Rated places
7
Average score
43/ 100
Most popular dish
Caesar Salad
Ristorante Roma
Ristorante Roma

Italian · Fine Dining

South Rangeline Road

Dinner features handmade pasta like Cacio E Pepe for $22, along with entrees such as Pollo Al Limone for $27.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Ristorante Roma
Ristorante Roma

Italian · Fine Dining

Veterans Way

Handmade pasta includes Cacio E Pepe for $22, and the menu also features locally sourced entrees like Filetto Al Gorgonzola for $44. Reservations recommended.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
HotBox Pizza
HotBox Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining

Weston Pointe Dr

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Sauce on the Side
Sauce on the Side

Italian · Pizza · Casual Dining

N Pennsylvania St

Handcrafted gourmet calzones include the Bull's Eye for $12.99, alongside a variety of fresh salads.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Ice Cream Shop · Dessert Shop · Italian

W Main St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Bazbeaux Pizza
Bazbeaux Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining

W Main St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Stacco House by Mammamia
Stacco House by Mammamia

Italian · Bakery · Dessert Shop

W Main St

Catering options include pans of rigatoni with meatballs for $91, alongside a menu of gelato, specialty desserts, coffee, wine, and baked goods.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Puccini's Pizza Pasta
Puccini's Pizza Pasta

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining

N Meridian St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
King Dough
King Dough

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining

Old Meridian St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Cantinetta Luca
Cantinetta Luca

Italian · Casual Dining

Dolores St. between Ocean and 7th

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Bella Pizzeria
Bella Pizzeria

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining

Clay Terrace Blvd

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine
Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine

Italian · Pizza · Seafood

Spring Mill Rd

Handmade pasta and seafood feature on the menu, including the $35 Vitello alla Sorrentina and the $23 Gigli di Zucca.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices