Carmel Italian

32 places in Carmel, Indiana

Roselli's Pizza and Olive Garden are the best-rated Italian restaurants in Carmel. See all 6 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.

64
Highest rated
Roselli's Pizza
Rated places
7
Average score
43/ 100
Most popular dish
Caesar Salad
64
Roselli's Pizza
Roselli's Pizza

Pizza · Buffet · Italian

W 106th St

Weekday specials include lasagna for $16.99, and the menu also features Chicago-style and thin-crust pizzas, subs, and catering services.

62
Olive Garden
Olive Garden

Italian · Family Style · Casual Dining

N Michigan Rd

62
Olive Garden
Olive Garden

Italian · Family Style · Casual Dining

N Michigan Rd

48
Mellow Mushroom
Mellow Mushroom

Pizza · Italian · Bar

E 116th St

26
Noodles and Company
Noodles and Company

Noodles · Italian · Thai

E Carmel Dr

23
Domino's Pizza
Domino's Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

S Guilford Rd

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

N College Ave

Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & Pub
Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & Pub

Pizza · Pub · Italian

W Main St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Greek's Pizzeria
Greek's Pizzeria

Pizza · Italian

Meeting House Rd

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Pizzology
Pizzology

Pizza · Italian · Bar

Hazel Dell Pkwy

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Greek's Pizzeria
Greek's Pizzeria

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

E Main St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Donatos Pizza
Donatos Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

S Range Line Rd

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

N Pennsylvania St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Donatos Pizza
Donatos Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

W 106th St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
HotBox Pizza
HotBox Pizza

Pizza · Chicken · Italian

E Carmel Dr

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Puccini's Pizza Pasta
Puccini's Pizza Pasta

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining

Harleston St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Greeks Pizzeria
Greeks Pizzeria

Pizza · Italian

N College Ave

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Fazolis
Fazolis

Italian · Pizza · Fast Food

E Carmel Dr

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Piada Italian Street Food
Piada Italian Street Food

Italian · Fast Food · Casual Dining

S Rangeline Rd

Customizable wraps, pasta bowls, and salads include the Carbonara Pasta for $8.90. The menu also features various power bowls and fresh salads.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
The Old Spaghetti Factory
The Old Spaghetti Factory

Italian · Family Style · Casual Dining

S Rangeline Rd

Not rated yetSee menu and prices