Greencastle American
41 places in Greencastle, Indiana
Buffalo Wild Wings and Arby's are the best-rated American restaurants in Greencastle. See all 6 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.
- Highest rated
- Buffalo Wild Wings
- Rated places
- 6
- Average score
- 11/ 100
- Most popular dish
- Fried Fish Sandwich

Burger · Bar and Grill · American
Indiana St S

Grill · American · Burger
S US Highway 231

Bar and Grill · American · Bar
Seminary St W

Pub · Bar · American
N Harrison St

American · Breakfast · Casual Dining
W Stardust Rd

Bar and Grill · American · Bar
Indiana St S

Pizza · Casual Dining · American
110 W Pat Rady Way

BBQ · American · Bar and Grill
Marina Dr
Their menu features pizzas like the Pepperoni Hot Honey for $14.99, alongside smoked BBQ dishes and Big Lug Canteen brews on tap.

BBQ · American · Casual Dining
W Pat Rady Way

American · Bar · Buffet
Seminary St W

Chicken · Fast Food · American
46 Putnam Plz

Family Style · American · Breakfast
1599 Ballard Ln
Lunch menu with hearty home cooking, such as a Margherita Pizza for $14, alongside various salads, sandwiches, and burgers.

American
7 E Franklin St
Daily menu featuring items like the Atlantic Salmon for $24, alongside various burgers, sandwiches, and chicken dishes.

American · Breakfast · Casual Dining
1st St

American · Casual Dining
S Jackson St
Brunch menu with items like the Whisk French Toast for $14, alongside savory options such as Patacones con Camarón for $14.

Breakfast · American
E State Road 240

Seafood · American · Grill
INDIANA 243
This hunting and fishing store serves a menu including a Tenderloin Sandwich for $8.99, alongside various 10" pizzas and chicken strips.

Burger · Fast Food · American
S College Ave
Late-night fast-food menu featuring the Garlic Cheeseburger for $9.30, alongside other burgers and fish. Open until midnight on Friday and Saturday.

American · Family Style · Breakfast
N Jackson St

American · Breakfast · Casual Dining
Stardust Rd