Greencastle American
41 places in Greencastle, Indiana
Buffalo Wild Wings and Arby's are the best-rated American restaurants in Greencastle. See all 6 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.
- Highest rated
- Buffalo Wild Wings
- Rated places
- 6
- Average score
- 11/ 100
- Most popular dish
- Fried Fish Sandwich

American · Buffet · Family Style
N Jackson St
Blue Plate Specials include country fried steak for $13, while lunch sandwich specials like the Angus burger are available for $10.

Bar and Grill · Bar · American
N Jackson St
Daily specials include country fried steak for $13, while the buffet features seafood options for $45. The bar serves beer, wine, and cocktails.

Bar and Grill · Bar · American
E Washington St

Burger · Fast Food · American
Putnam County Plz

Family Style · American · Bar and Grill
12 E Washington St

American · Casual Dining · Sandwich Shop
DePauw Campus

Bar · Bar and Grill · American
Main St W

BBQ · American · Casual Dining
E Berry St, Greencastle, IN 46135
Serving hickory-smoked meats from a food truck, the All American Smash Combo is $18.99. The menu also features various BBQ nachos and comforting side dishes.

Bar and Grill · American · Family Style
E Washington St

Casual Dining · American · Deli
E State Road 236

Deli · Sandwich Shop · American
N Main St
Fresh seafood market offering a variety of lobsters starting at $9.99, alongside fresh Atlantic haddock, codfish, and halibut.

American · Bar and Grill
Franklin St W
Serving nostalgic comfort food all day, the menu features the Almost Home Burger for $15, alongside a variety of classic sandwiches and hearty entrees.

Family Style · American · Casual Dining
1058 Indianapolis Rd
The menu features comfort food like an Athens Gyro for $9.99, alongside a variety of melts, sandwiches, and grilled options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

Wine Bar · American · Bar
W Washington St





