Indianapolis American
1,013 places in Indianapolis, Indiana
Bluebeard and Salt on Mass are the best-rated American restaurants in Indianapolis. See all 227 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.
- Highest rated
- Bluebeard
- Rated places
- 227
- Average score
- 24/ 100
- Most popular dish
- Caesar Salad

Steakhouse · American · Seafood
Route 7800 Col H Weir C
The menu features steakhouse classics like the $52 New York Strip, alongside seafood, pizza, and a notable wine selection.

Craft Beer · Bar · American
E Southport Rd

Bar · Bar and Grill · American
Broad Ripple Ave
Drink specials include well mixed drinks, Vegas bombs, and any draft beer for $2 each.

Bar · American · Bar and Grill
Guilford Ave

Sandwich Shop · Deli · American
Michigan Rd

Chicken · Fast Food · American
E Washington St

Sandwich Shop · American · Fast Food
7521 US Hwy 31 S

Bar · American · Craft Beer
156 E Market St
The menu features chicken wings and a variety of entrees, including a New York Strip for $28.50 and a Salmon Entree for $21.

Bar · Burger · American
3701 W 16th St

Sandwich Shop · American · Fast Food
3905 West 96th Street

Bar · Pub · American
20 N Pennsylvania St

BBQ · American · Casual Dining
US Highway 31 S

Chicken · American · Family Style
Michigan Rd

Bar · American
S West St
The menu features comfort food like the $10 fried chicken and hoecake sandwich, alongside smoked pork plates, vegan wings, and various fry options.

Bar · American · Wine Bar
Virginia Ave
Toasted marshmallow whiskey is served alongside a menu featuring the $38 Bone-in Pork Chop and the $23 Bistro Burger.

Chicken · Fast Food · American
N Post Rd
Takeaway menu featuring crispy chicken tenders like the Nap Tenders for $12.99, alongside chicken sandwiches, Nap Fries, and various drinks.

Seafood · Chicken · American
W 38th St
A casual menu featuring Atlanta-style wings and seafood, such as three whole wings for $6.99, alongside chicken sandwiches, burgers, and salads.

American · Bar and Grill · Craft Beer
Executive Dr

American · Casual Dining
W 30th St
Serving soul food favorites like a Catfish Dinner for $16.75, the menu also features pork chops, chicken, and sweet potato pie.

Bar · Craft Beer · American
7800 Col H Weir Cook Mem Dr