Indianapolis Italian

219 places in Indianapolis, Indiana

Mama Carolla's and Vito Provolone's are the best-rated Italian restaurants in Indianapolis. See all 76 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.

93
Highest rated
Mama Carolla's
Rated places
76
Average score
23/ 100
Most popular dish
Caesar Salad
15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

E Southport Rd

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

E Southport Rd

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

N Keystone Ave

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

S Emerson Ave

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

N Keystone Ave

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

E 38th St

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

E Washington St

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

Ditch Rd

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

Kentucky Ave

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

Rockville Rd

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

Indiana Ave

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

N Shadeland Ave

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

E 82nd St

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

W 71st St

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

Emerson Way

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

E Washington St

15
Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

W 10th St

15
Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

S Madison Ave

15
Donatos Pizza
Donatos Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

S Franklin Rd

13
Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut

Pizza · Italian · Chicken

N Mitthoeffer Rd