Vota has collected menus from 28 places in New Castle. The dishes that come up most often on these menus are mac and cheese, which is listed at 9 of these places, followed by bbq chicken pizza and pulled pork sandwich.
New Castle Indiana
146 places in New Castle, Indiana
- Highest rated
- Culver's
- Rated places
- 24
- Average score
- 13/ 100
- Most popular dish
- Mac and Cheese

Coffee Shop · Breakfast · Bakery
S Memorial Dr

American · Breakfast · Casual Dining
S 15th St
Serving traditional comfort food, the menu includes a #1 One Egg Any Style for $6.99 alongside various breakfast sandwiches and pancake options.

Ice Cream Shop · Dessert Shop
1701 S Main St

Burger · Bar and Grill · American
S 14th St
Dinner options include the New York Strip Dinner for $29.95, alongside burgers like the Courier Burger for $14.49, plus live music, golf, and axe throwing.

Coffee Shop · American
22 N Jefferson St

Bar · Wine Bar · Pub
Locust St

Burger · Bar and Grill
S Mill Rd
This brewpub serves bison burgers like the $14.99 American Bison Burger, along with ribeyes, brisket nachos, and a variety of salads and sandwiches.

Pizza · Burger · Ice Cream Shop
E Main St

Pizza · Sandwich Shop · American
S Broad St

Chicken · Fast Food · American
Trojan Ln

Bakery
2405 W Co Rd 100 South

Grill · American · Bar and Grill
S State Road 3

Wine Bar · American · Bar
W COUNTY ROAD 62
A menu of BBQ-style bites and snacks, including a Pulled Pork Sandwich for $12, plus charcuterie boards, nachos, and various sides.

Pizza · Italian · Family Style
Broad St

Family Style · Grill · Caribbean
7642 W County Road 350 S

Japanese · Sushi · Steakhouse
2201 S Memorial Dr
Daily fresh fish is used for sushi rolls like the Tuna Avocado Roll for $7.25, alongside a selection of hibachi and Japanese-style grilled steakhouse dishes.

Pizza · Italian · Family Style
N Vine St

Sandwich Shop · Deli · Fast Food
S Memorial Dr

Mexican · Casual Dining · Taco Shop
S 22nd St

Fast Food
1902 S Memorial Dr