New Castle Pizza
20 places in New Castle, Indiana
Domino's Pizza and Papa Johns Pizza are the best-rated pizzerias in New Castle. See all 4 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.
- Highest rated
- Domino's Pizza
- Rated places
- 4
- Average score
- 17/ 100
- Most popular dish
- BBQ Chicken Pizza

Pizza · Sandwich Shop · Casual Dining
S Memorial Dr
House-baked rolls are used for grinders like the Ham & Cheese for $8.99, and the menu also includes a wide selection of steak, chicken, and meatball options.

Pizza · Italian · Family Style
S Memorial Dr

Pizza · Fast Food
5884 S Wilbur Wright Rd

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop
Maple Vlg

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
Locust St
Lunch specials include a pizza slice and a drink for $4.49, while dinner options feature spaghetti & meatballs for $11.99.

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
N Walnut St
For lunch, The Lunch Special is $5.95, and the menu also includes ribs, lasagna, and specialty pizzas with gluten-free or cauliflower crust options.

Pizza · Chicken · Casual Dining
E Main St

Pizza · American
N Vine St

Pizza · Taco Shop · Breakfast
Broad St

Pizza · Italian · Family Style
E Main St
This casual spot features a salad bar and a variety of pies, including the BBQ Ranch Chicken Bacon for $9.25, alongside options like The Hammer and Meatball Sub.

Pizza · Burger · Ice Cream Shop
E Main St

Pizza · Sandwich Shop · American
S Broad St

Pizza · Italian · Family Style
Broad St

Pizza · Italian · Family Style
N Vine St

Italian · Pizza · Casual Dining
1326 Broad St

Pizza · Sandwich Shop · Family Style
Q Ave
This family-friendly spot serves a Full Submarine (12") for $9.49, alongside salads, desserts, and various breadsticks.