Jeff's Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Family Style

A look at Jeff's Pizza's menu and price range

Chicken Supreme Salad
Vota illustration
Chicken Supreme Salad$11.50
Turkey Lovers
Vota illustration
Turkey Lovers$9.25
Little Italy
Vota illustration
Little Italy$9.25
Vota

See the full menu

Get the free Vota app

This establishment in New Castle, Knightstown serves as a local hub for pizza, Italian, and family style dining. It caters to those seeking a casual environment to enjoy classic comfort foods with friends or family.

The menu at Jeff's Pizza in New Castle offers a wide variety of specialty pizzas, toasted subs, pasta, and appetizers. Most specialty pizzas are priced between $8.50 and $39.95, while toasted subs are consistently priced at $9.25. Pasta dishes range from $8.75 to $9.25, and appetizers vary from $4.50 to $21.50. Guests frequently select from the daily specials, which include various combinations of pizzas and sides at set price points.

New Castle functions as a classic Midwestern crossroads, echoing the industrial persistence found in small-town Pennsylvania or the Ruhr Valley. The local food culture relies on hearty, reliable portions that prioritize sustenance over pretense. Visitors here find a community that values consistency, where a meal is judged by its ability to reliably satisfy after a long week. It is a place where the table acts as the primary social anchor, reflecting a regional preference for unadorned, filling Italian-inspired fare over the fleeting trends of metropolitan dining.

  • Jeff's Pizza offers a diverse menu featuring specialty pizzas, toasted subs, pasta, and various appetizers.
  • The restaurant provides a family style dining atmosphere suitable for groups and local residents.
  • Specialty pizza prices range from $8.50 to $39.95 depending on size and ingredients.
  • Toasted subs are available at a fixed price point of $9.25 for all varieties.
  • The location in New Castle serves as a central spot for residents to access traditional Italian-style comfort food.

Download the Vota app for iPhone and Android for the full menu and detailed information.

Created on Oct 30, 2026

This article was created by Vota’s editorial team with the help of AI.

AddressE Main St, IN
CityKnightstown, United States of America

Location

Vota recommends

What are you in the mood for?

The ranking

Best Pizza in New Castle

4 places ranked by guests