Top Hat Two

Top Hat Two is a family style establishment located in New Castle that functions as both a pizza and sandwich shop. The menu focuses on classic American comfort foods including a variety of pizzas, submarine sandwiches, and side dishes.

Menu and pricing at Top Hat Two

The menu at Top Hat Two in New Castle features a wide variety of pizzas, including specialty feasts and build your own options, alongside a selection of subs, sandwiches, and sides. Prices for pizza range from $13.89 to $31.49 for feast options, while individual submarine sandwiches are priced at $5.79 for a half sub and $9.49 for a full sub. Other menu items include sides like breadsticks at $6.09, salads starting at $4.59, and sweet treats such as the $7.79 pizza cookie. New Castle maintains a traditional Midwestern food culture where diners prioritize hearty, communal meals that transition easily from quick lunches to family dinners. The area reflects a pragmatic approach to dining, emphasizing establishments that provide consistent, reliable fare in a straightforward setting. You will find that the local preference leans toward accessible, high-calorie comfort food that serves as the social anchor for neighborhood gatherings. • This establishment offers a family style dining environment suitable for all ages. • Pizza options include diverse configurations like the Royal Feast at $13.89 and Meat Feast at $31.49. • Submarine sandwiches are available in both 6 inch and 12 inch sizes, priced at $5.79 and $9.49 respectively. • The menu includes various sides such as Bosco Sticks and breadsticks, both priced at $6.09. • Weekly deals provide structured pricing options, such as the Monday special priced at $28.99.