New York Ice Cream Shop
840 places in New York, New York
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream and Sugar Hill Creamery are the best-rated ice cream shops in New York. See all 26 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.
- Highest rated
- Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
- Rated places
- 26
- Average score
- 21/ 100
- Most popular dish
- Chicken Sandwich

Shake Shack
Burger · Fast Food · Ice Cream Shop
Varick St
Counter-serve hamburgers, like the Double ShackBurger for $13.89, also offers frozen custard and their special sauce. Open daily until 23:00.

Pasta Louise
Italian · Ice Cream Shop
8th Ave
Fresh pasta menu featuring Slow Cooked Bolognese for $24, plus options like Cacio E Pepe for $16.50, wine, and ice cream.






