New York Italian

3,425 places in New York, New York

Fiaschetteria Pistoia and I Sodi are the best-rated Italian restaurants in New York. See all 256 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.

98
Highest rated
Fiaschetteria Pistoia
Rated places
261
Average score
33/ 100
Most popular dish
Cacio e Pepe Pasta
85
Trattoria Bianca
Trattoria Bianca

Italian · Pizza · Casual Dining

8th Ave

85
Settepani
Settepani

Italian · Bakery · Dessert Shop

Lenox Ave

85
Porto Salvo
Porto Salvo

Italian · Bar

E 161st St

83
Canto
Canto

Italian · Casual Dining

Broadway

82
Lilly's Cocktail and Wine
Lilly's Cocktail and Wine

Wine Bar · Italian · Tapas

W 72nd St

82
Flora
Flora

Italian · Wine Bar

8th Ave

The dinner menu features dishes like the $39 Cappello del Prete All'Aglianico, alongside a selection of wine, beer, cocktails, and espresso.

82
Felice Montague
Felice Montague

Italian · Seafood · Wine Bar

Montague St

82
Piccoli Trattoria
Piccoli Trattoria

Italian · Casual Dining · Wine Bar

6th Ave

Homemade pastas include Butternut Squash & Ricotta Ravioli for $22, and Rigatoni Bolognese for $22.

81
Ai Fiori
Ai Fiori

Italian · French · Fine Dining

5th Ave

Dinner menus feature dishes like Risotto for $46, alongside a selection of over 1000 wines.

80
Cafe Spaghetti
Cafe Spaghetti

Italian · Casual Dining · Bar

Union St

80
Evelina
Evelina

Italian · Mediterranean · Casual Dining

De Kalb Ave

Dinner features wood-fired dishes and pastas like Pappardelle for $29, alongside small plates and cocktails.

78
Il Caffe Latte
Il Caffe Latte

Italian · Coffee Shop · Breakfast

Lenox Ave

78
Dino
Dino

Italian

Dekalb Ave

75
Emmett's on Grove
Emmett's on Grove

Pizza · Italian · Bar

Grove St

75
Fiaschetteria Pistoia
Fiaschetteria Pistoia

Italian · Wine Bar

7th Ave S

Pappardelle al Cinghiale for $15, with other pasta dishes like Ravioli Mugellani al Ragù for $14.

72
Primo Amore
Primo Amore

Italian · Family Style · Casual Dining

34-33 Francis Lewis Blvd

71
La Nonna
La Nonna

Italian · Wine Bar · Casual Dining

Kent Ave

71
Gus's
Gus's

Steakhouse · Italian · Bar

Union St

69
Armonie
Armonie

Italian · Pizza · Sandwich Shop

Park Ave

69
Ace's Pizza
Ace's Pizza

Pizza · Italian

Rockefeller Plz

Happy Hour offers include half-priced pizzas for $1, wings, and Budweisers for $3.