91

3 ratings · How the score works

Sailor

American · Casual Dining

Sailor in Brooklyn offers a seafood-focused dining experience. Their menu prominently features classic American seafood dishes, with an emphasis on fresh, seasonal catches.

People seek out this restaurant for its direct approach to seafood in a neighborhood known for its diverse culinary landscape. It caters to those desiring a straightforward, quality seafood meal without excessive frills, a welcome counterpoint to more experimental kitchens. This restaurant is aimed towards people who appreciate well-prepared seafood and a relaxed dining atmosphere.

Corn + Goat Gouda Quiche with Bacon Vinaigrette
Vota illustration
Corn + Goat Gouda Quiche with Bacon Vinaigrette$24
Egg Tonnato + Chives
Vota illustration
Egg Tonnato + Chives$6
Chicory Salad
Vota illustration
Chicory Salad$18
Vota

See the full menu

Get the free Vota app

  • Located in Fort Greene, a historic Brooklyn neighborhood.
  • Known for its fresh, American seafood preparations.
  • Entrees typically range from $30 to $50.
  • Features a rotating selection of oysters.
  • Offers a curated wine list and craft cocktails.

Fort Greene, with its tree-lined streets and brownstone architecture, has long been a cultural hub in Brooklyn, boasting institutions like the Brooklyn Academy of Music. The food culture here is a blend of old-school neighborhood favorites and newer, chef-driven establishments. While you'll find everything from Ethiopian to Italian, seafood restaurants like Sailor tap into a perennial American appreciation for fresh catches, offering a refined yet accessible take on coastal dining. It's a place where the pre-theater crowd mixes with long-time residents, all seeking quality fare in an area that feels distinctively New York, yet retains a village-like charm.

Created on Sep 30, 2026

This article was created by Vota’s editorial team with the help of Gemini AI.

AddressDekalb Ave, NY
CityNew York, United States of America
Reserve a table

Location

Best places nearby

The highest rated places close to Sailor.

Local restaurants nearby

Dekalb Ave, NY

The ranking

Best American in New York

722 places ranked by guests

Sailor is number 18 on the list