Shirley Pizza
15 places in Shirley, New York
Pizza in Shirley: discover the best-rated places on Vota, ranked by real local diner votes, not ads or fake reviews.
- Highest rated
- Pizza Hut
- Rated places
- 1
- Average score
- 13/ 100

Tonino's Pizza
Pizza · Italian
Surrey Cir
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Savarona's Pizzeria
Pizza · Italian
Montauk Hwy
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Joes Pizza
Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
William Floyd Pkwy
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Anthony's Pizza
Pizza · Italian · Fast Food
Mastic Rd
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Vincent's Pizzeria
Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop
44 Surrey Circle
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Carlo's Pizza
Pizza · Italian
Glen Dr
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

JC Pizzeria
Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
Surrey Cir
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Tommy's Pizzeria & Bubble Tea
Pizza · Tea House · Sandwich Shop
44 D Surrey Circle
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Aliyana's Pizzeria
Pizza · Italian · American
Mastic Rd
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Los Amigos Pizzeria
Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
351 William Floyd Pkwy
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Buona Fortuna Pizza
Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
Surrey Cir
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

La Vespa
Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
Moriches-Middle Island Rd
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Joe's Pizza
Pizza · Italian
433 William Floyd Pkwy
Not rated yetSee menu and prices

Hero Haven Pizza & More
Pizza · Sandwich Shop · Breakfast
Neighborhood Rd
Not rated yetSee menu and prices