Williamsburg American

160 places in Williamsburg, Virginia

Fat Tuna Grill and Oyster House and Fat Canary are the best-rated American restaurants in Williamsburg. See all 49 rated places, ranked by diners.

Rated places
49
Average score
42/ 100
Most popular dish
Cheese Burger
93
Fat Tuna Grill and Oyster House
Fat Tuna Grill and Oyster House

Seafood · Bar and Grill · American

1433 Richmond Rd

A family-friendly seafood restaurant known for its oyster house and grill specialties, like Crab Ravioli for $24.99.

91
Fat Canary
Fat Canary

American · Fine Dining · Wine Bar

W Duke of Gloucester St

Seasonal menu featuring dishes like pan seared sea scallops for $40, alongside a cheese shop and patio.

88
Blue Talon Bistro
Blue Talon Bistro

French · American

Prince George St

The menu features brasserie dishes like the $21.95 Cubano Francais, alongside options such as Rotisserie Chicken, Steak Frites, and Seared Scallops.

86
Berret's Seafood and Taphouse Grill
Berret's Seafood and Taphouse Grill

Seafood · Bar and Grill · American

S Boundary St

Regional seafood menu featuring Berret's Baked Backfin Crabcakes for $39, plus microbrews and outdoor grilled options.

83
Five Forks Cafe
Five Forks Cafe

American · Breakfast

John Tyler Hwy

83
King's Arms Tavern
King's Arms Tavern

American · Family Style · Casual Dining

E Duke of Gloucester St

Hearty American specialties include Root Beer of Chowning's Tavern for $4.75, plus a selection of teas, snacks, and sauces. Open Monday and Thursday to Sunday.

81
Food For Thought
Food For Thought

American · Casual Dining · Vegetarian

Richmond Rd

American cuisine with global influences, try the Fork Tender Pot Roast for $23. Other dishes include Grandma'S Meatloaf and Island Jerk Chicken.

80
Waypoint Seafood & Grill
Waypoint Seafood & Grill

Seafood · Grill · American

Quarterpath Rd

77
Paul's Deli
Paul's Deli

Italian · American · Deli

New Town Ave

The menu features a variety of subs like the Meatball Sub for $10.49, alongside options like the Italian and Pastrami.

76
LongHorn Steakhouse
LongHorn Steakhouse

Steakhouse · American · Casual Dining

Monticello Ave

Serves grilled beef and other American dishes, like Flo's Filet®* for $24.99 and Outlaw Ribeye®* for $31.49.

76
Pierce's Pitt Bar-B-Que
Pierce's Pitt Bar-B-Que

BBQ · American · Casual Dining

E Rochambeau Dr

Counter-serve barbecue restaurant established in 1961, specializing in pulled pork, ribs, and chicken. A Jumbo Pork costs "$6.99".

70
Aberdeen Barn
Aberdeen Barn

Steakhouse · Seafood · American

Richmond Rd

Classic steakhouse with an open hearth grill, featuring a Top Sirloin* for $31.99 and a raw bar.

68
DoG Street Pub
DoG Street Pub

Pub · American · Bar

E Duke of Gloucester St

Gastropub menu with items like a $14.95 griddled hot dog or $16.95 corned beef brisket. Open until 3:00 AM most nights.

68
Not Another Pancake House
Not Another Pancake House

Breakfast · Brunch · American

Richmond Rd

63
Burgers on the Edge
Burgers on the Edge

Burger · American · Casual Dining

455 Merrimac Trl

Craft smash burgers like the "Bacon is My Jam" for $10.99, plus giant breakfast burritos and chicken dishes.

59
Outback Steakhouse
Outback Steakhouse

Steakhouse · Seafood · American

Richmond Rd

Steakhouse fare with an Aussie 3-Course Meal for $14.99. Also known for steaks and seafood.

53
Eagles
Eagles

Steakhouse · American · Casual Dining

Kingsmill Rd

An American steakhouse offering seasonal dishes like the Chef's Meatloaf for $21, with comfort food options also available.

49
Cracker Barrel Old Country Store
Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

American · Family Style · Breakfast

Bypass Rd

48
Shorty's Diner
Shorty's Diner

American · Ice Cream Shop

Merrimac Trl

Brunch includes items like the Steak & Eggs for $21.99, alongside a variety of breakfast sandwiches, biscuits, and shaved ice flavors.

48
First Watch
First Watch

Breakfast · Brunch · American

Monticello Ave