Indianapolis Italian

219 places in Indianapolis, Indiana

Mama Carolla's and Vito Provolone's are the best-rated Italian restaurants in Indianapolis. See all 76 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.

93
Highest rated
Mama Carolla's
Rated places
76
Average score
23/ 100
Most popular dish
Caesar Salad
Godfather's Pizza Express
Godfather's Pizza Express

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food

Brookville Rd

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Pizza Hut Express
Pizza Hut Express

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food

W. 38th Street

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Jack's Pizza
Jack's Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining

Lafayette Rd Ste L

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub
Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub

Pizza · Pub · Italian

E Pearl St

This family-friendly eatery serves build-your-own pizzas and pasta, such as the $13.95 Cavatappi a la vodka, alongside sandwiches and microbrews.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Bazbeaux Pizza
Bazbeaux Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining

E Massachusetts Ave

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Jack's Pizza
Jack's Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food

E Washington St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Donatos
Donatos

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

S Franklin Rd Ste 100

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Mia Pizzaria
Mia Pizzaria

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining

N Shadeland Ave

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Pronta Pizzeria
Pronta Pizzeria

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food

W Washington St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Pizza Hut Express
Pizza Hut Express

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

N Keystone Ave

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
HotBox Pizza
HotBox Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food

E Southport Rd

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Papa Murphy's Take N Bake Pizza
Papa Murphy's Take N Bake Pizza

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian

E 86th St Ste 53

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Pasquales
Pasquales

Pizza · Italian · Buffet

Kentucky Ave

Casual dining with an all-you-can-eat option, including a Meat Lover's Pizza for $11.41, plus a variety of stromboli, lasagna, and sandwiches.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Chicago's Pizza
Chicago's Pizza

Pizza · Buffet · Italian

E Stop 11 Rd

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
D & C Pizza
D & C Pizza

Pizza · Italian

N Arlington Ave

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Exotic on the Run
Exotic on the Run

Seafood · Italian · Chicken

N Post Rd

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Harsi's Subs N Pizza
Harsi's Subs N Pizza

Pizza · Sandwich Shop · Italian

Georgetown Rd

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Iaria's Italian
Iaria's Italian

Italian · Pizza · Family Style

S College Ave

Serving classic pasta and pizza since 1933, the menu includes spaghetti with tomato sauce for $35, alongside various meat dishes and fettuccine options.

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Manhattan Pizzeria
Manhattan Pizzeria

Pizza · Italian

W 56th St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices
Donatos Pizza
Donatos Pizza

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop

E 62nd St

Not rated yetSee menu and prices