Indianapolis Italian
219 places in Indianapolis, Indiana
Mama Carolla's and Vito Provolone's are the best-rated Italian restaurants in Indianapolis. See all 76 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.
- Highest rated
- Mama Carolla's
- Rated places
- 76
- Average score
- 23/ 100
- Most popular dish
- Caesar Salad

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
6020 E 82nd St
Menu options for takeout or delivery include the Meat Lover's Pizza for $21.99, alongside various pasta meals, panzerotti, and individual pizza slices.

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop
N Shadeland Ave

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian
Moller Rd

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop
Georgetown Rd

Pizza · Italian
N Illinois St
Lunch specials include a Butler Bite for $20, and the menu also features sandwiches like the Meatball Sando for $12 and various grilled pizzas.

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food
5741 E 71st St

Pizza · Italian · Family Style
E 96th St

Pizza · Italian
E Washington St

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food
Indiana Ave

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food
W 10th St
This counter-serve spot offers thin-crust pies like the Carnivore for $19.99, alongside various toppings, sauces, and the $7.99 Caprese Sandwich.

Pizza · Italian
8702 Keystone Xing
Stone hearth baked pizzas include the $16 Margherita and the $20 Seth's Pie, with a seasonal menu that also features Tuscan White Bean for $6.

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop
W 86th St

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food
Intech Commons Dr

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
E Southeastern Ave

Italian · Seafood · Bar
S Delaware St

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop
E 86th St

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian
E 71st St

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
N Illinois St
Pizza and kitchen-style fare with pickup options, including a Spicy Ghost 'Rita for $10.99, plus Omg Cookies and frozen treats.

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
N Illinois St

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
4930 Lafayette Rd Ste L