Indianapolis Italian
219 places in Indianapolis, Indiana
Mama Carolla's and Vito Provolone's are the best-rated Italian restaurants in Indianapolis. See all 76 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.
- Highest rated
- Mama Carolla's
- Rated places
- 76
- Average score
- 23/ 100
- Most popular dish
- Caesar Salad

Mediterranean · Italian · Deli
E 54th St

Pizza · Italian · Vegetarian
N Arlington Ave

Pizza · Italian · Family Style
S Emerson Ave

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian
E Thompson Rd

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop
E Market St
Quick-serve menu with a Meatball Parmigiana Sub for $10.50, plus a variety of thin- and thick-crust pizzas, beer, and wine.

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
Broad Ripple Ave

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
Southeastern Ave

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
Madison Ave

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food
E Southport Rd

Italian · Fine Dining · Seafood
Ruth Dr

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop
E Washington St

Pizza · Italian
Michigan Rd

Pizza · Italian
N Mitthoeffer Rd, B6

Pizza · Sandwich Shop · Italian
N Mitthoeffer Rd
The menu features pasta meals like lasagna for $8.39, alongside classic pizza pies, salads, and subs.

Italian · Fast Food · Pizza
W 86th St

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
E 82nd St

Italian · Thai · Casual Dining
W Pike Plaza Rd

Ice Cream Shop · Dessert Shop · Italian
S Emerson Ave
Hand-crafted desserts include a flavor flight for $10, along with various ice cream sizes, acai bowls, milkshakes, and dairy-free options.

Pizza · Italian · Fast Food
49 W Maryland St
This menu includes classic Italian dishes like Baked Ziti for $7.49, alongside a variety of pizzas, calzones, and strombolis.

Pizza · Italian
Virginia Ave
Serving set menus for events since 2013, such as the Smoky BBQ for $24, alongside a selection of classic set menus and catering options.