Indianapolis Italian
219 places in Indianapolis, Indiana
Mama Carolla's and Vito Provolone's are the best-rated Italian restaurants in Indianapolis. See all 76 rated places, ranked by real diners' comparisons.
- Highest rated
- Mama Carolla's
- Rated places
- 76
- Average score
- 23/ 100
- Most popular dish
- Caesar Salad

Pizza · Italian
Georgetown Rd

Italian · Family Style · Casual Dining
E 86th St

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
W 86th St

Pizza · Italian
E Stop 11 Rd

Pizza · Italian
N Illinois St
Full-size kitchen menu with dishes like Lasagna for $99.99, plus a wide selection of pasta, chicken, and seafood options.

Pizza · Italian
E 10th St
Build-your-own calzones start at $8.89, and the menu also features a wide variety of toppings, traditional pizzas, and a $10.99 9″ pizza cookie.

Pizza · Italian · Family Style
Bluff Rd

Pizza · Italian · Wine Bar
E 49th St
Stone-hearth baked pizzas include Seth's Pie for $20, alongside seasonal Italian bites like the $6 Tuscan White Bean.

Pizza · Italian
Carson Ave

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
E 82nd St

Italian · Fast Food · Pizza
E Washington St

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
Rockville Rd

Italian · Fast Food · Pizza
S Madison Ave

Pizza · Fast Food · Italian
E Southport Rd

Pizza · Italian · Sandwich Shop
Madison Ave

Italian · Family Style · Casual Dining
IN
Family-style portions include Mom's Lasagna for $27, alongside a variety of pasta, seafood, and chicken dishes available for dine-in, delivery, or catering.

Italian · Pizza · Sandwich Shop
W Michigan St

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
Carrollton Ave
Made-to-order pizzas include a 10" pizza for $10, and the menu also features pastas like spaghetti for $12 and various calzones.

Pizza · Italian · Bar
E Massachusetts Ave

Pizza · Italian · Casual Dining
W 86th St